I used to like to read Peggy Noonan. She was interesting, usually choosing appealing subjects to write about; and she wrote in an engaging style. She was a good columnist.
But now she's just a pundit and I’ve gotten tired of her. She’s getting old, and with age I suppose goes some crankiness. Also, usually with age, one foregoes—at least outwardly—the certain fullness of one’s self, the conceit that the youthful often muster. But dear old Peg seems to be still in that arrogant (pundit) mode.
I began to suspect her when she backed Obama for president. She had allowed other left of center ideas to creep into her work too. But what is really upsetting is her hostility to Sarah Palin. Now Sarah Palin is good, and Peg may be a little jealous of that. It may be she has a concern that one may not be as good as one thinks herself to be. Palin is probably the most prominent and newsworthy politician after the president. Yes, she may be a bit inexperienced in national politics; she may be a little weak in international relations; she may not be a foremost economist. But these are not fundamental personality or knowledge flaws. The lady does know right from wrong—more than one can say about ninety-five percent of current politicians.
For nine months now, old Peg has been acting the harpy against Governor Palin. She picks on this popular favorite with a sour wit. (but then she also backed Barak Obama). One wonders if she left all her rational thinking in the Reagan White House. Back in October Noonan raked Ms. Palin over the coals; and again, recently, she took Ms. Palin to task after her thoughtful resignation as Alaska’s governor.
Part of the isue with Noonan and other writers, both left and right, seems to be that Ms. Palin is not of the Ivy League, BosNYWash corridor pundit corps. But stop and think Peg—maybe that’s why she is popular. Maybe the citizenry of the U.S. is getting tired of the elites of the East and their haughty attitude and “we know what is best for all of you” thinking.
It seems that Ms. Noonan might want to consider why Palin is so popular instead of just blasting away with a venomous pen and, even if she does not agree with her, give her the credit she deserves for what she has done in Alaska and to the grassroots base of her party..
I don’t know why the WSJ keeps Noonan on their columnist roles There are better writers out there more in tune with the Journal’s ideals.